The Best Non-Toxic Pillows for a Blissful Sleep

You asked, and we delivered. Or should we say tested and delivered. Purchasing new pillows typically isn’t at the top of one’s shopping list, but according to sleep.org, you should replace your sleepyhead cushions every one to two years. Think about it—that’s a year’s worth of oil, grime, and dust collected within the item you rest your delicate skin on.

When buying new pillows, you should be sure to do your research. In today’s case, use our trusted opinions on where to find options that pass the Poosh test. We had three of our team members sleep on a set of different pillows, and below we’re bringing you the results on which fluffy piece of heaven won the prime spot in each of our beds.

Shop Now

Down Alternative Pillow

Price: $59

Parachute

“I only use down alternative because down gives me allergies. I really enjoyed the Parachute Medium pillow—it reminded me of a luxe pillow in a five-star hotel, with its plushness. It was definitely on the softer side, perfect for folding up and cuddling into.” – Sarah Howard

Shop Now

Easy Breather Side Sleeper

Price: $119

Nest

“I’ve never seen a pillow like this before. It’s shaped like a bow tie, which I thought would look awkward on my bed, but a pillowcase fills in the gap to keep it looking uniform. It’s so soft and squishy, and really molded to my body so I didn’t feel like I was fighting against it or struggling to get comfortable. I’m a really restless sleeper and found that with this, I fell asleep faster and also remembered my dreams, which never happens. I also loved the shape because I could hook my arm under the little nook and sleep on my stomach.” – Rachel Godfrey

Shop Now

Eden Queen Pillow

Price: $80

Coop

“This pillow is kind of insane because it comes with an extra sleeve of fluff. It’s fully customizable so you can add and remove fluff to your liking. For a stomach sleeper like me, it recommended removing a third of the stuffing. I felt like I was taking out so much and ended up with a huge bag of filler. I liked the feel of the final pillow, but then I was left with so much excess that it made me feel wasteful. I still haven’t thrown it all away and am trying to think of another use for it. Anyone out there need a giant bag of stuffing? I’m your girl.” – Rachel Godfrey

Shop Now

Down Alternative Pillow

Price: $58

Snowe

“I like to stack my pillows from firmest to fluffiest with my favorite on top. After testing out the selection, I found myself leaning toward Snowe. It provides just enough structure but at the same time felt like a little baby cloud every night.” – Michelle Scanga

Up next, be the first to know our weekly content and sign up for our Poosh newsletter.

Congratulations You're on the list.

Related Articles

Congratulations
You're on the list.