Finding a clean mascara that actually works as well as the drugstore or designer formula you’ve been using since you first learned how to apply makeup can be challenging. Luckily, we did the heavy lifting for you and tested the new(ish) conscious beauty brand Saie’s Mascara 101. Our editor, Michelle Scanga, gave the $24 item a whirl and was so impressed with the results, she now uses it as her full-time mascara option. “I was hesitant because I like my lashes to look full and lengthy without applying dozens of layers. Within a few swipes, I could tell I was going to be into it. I think I put seven to eight coats on each eye, and my lashes looked just as poppin’ as when I use my not-so-clean product.” Saie’s safe ingredients include beeswax, shea butter, and their hydra-mineral complex, which lends a buildable application all while hydrating and nourishing your pretty lashes. Shop this week’s Poosh-approved clean mascara here.