Skip to main content
Close Close

Congratulations
You're on the list.

Make sure to check your spam folder so that our emails are always delivered into your inbox.
xo, Kourt
Give your inbox
and your life

the Poosh it needs.
By clicking SIGN UP, you agree to receive emails from Poosh and agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.
Free Shipping on All Domestic Orders.
  • HEALTH + WELLNESS
  • LIFE + STYLE
  • HOME + ENTERTAINING
  • KKB
Poosh
  • instagram pinterest facebook twitter youtube join newsletter
  • Shop
  • search
  • search
  • body
  • diy
  • fitness
  • Giving Back
  • health
  • mind
  • Relationships
  • Sexual Wellness
  • soul
Why You Should Elevate Your Legs for 20 Minutes a Day
Why You Should Elevate Your Legs for 20 Minutes a Day
Weird Dreams? These are the Most Common Culprits
Weird Dreams? These are the Most Common Culprits
What Is Shadow Work and How Do I Start It?
What Is Shadow Work and How Do I Start It?
What To Avoid When You’re Newly Dating Someone
What To Avoid When You’re Newly Dating Someone
3 Ways Bondage Can Bring You Closer Together
3 Ways Bondage Can Bring You Closer Together
5-Minute Wake-Up Pilates Routine
5-Minute Wake-Up Pilates Routine
  • Adulting
  • beauty
  • guides
  • Hacks
  • style
  • travel
Hot Rollers Are Back, Baby
Hot Rollers Are Back, Baby
You’re Giving Compliments Wrong
You’re Giving Compliments Wrong
How to get Naturally Plump Lips in Minutes
How to get Naturally Plump Lips in Minutes
We’re Loving Latte Makeup for Fall—Here are the 3 Must-Have Products You Need For It
We’re Loving Latte Makeup for Fall—Here are the 3 Must-Have Products You Need For It
How To Keep Your Tan After Summer, According to Jennifer Lopez’s Spray Tan Artist
How To Keep Your Tan After Summer, According to Jennifer Lopez’s Spray Tan Artist
Kendall’s Stylist Shares Her 5 Must-Know Fall Fashion Trends
Kendall’s Stylist Shares Her 5 Must-Know Fall Fashion Trends
  • decor
  • entertaining
  • kids
  • motherhood
  • Playlists
  • recipes
Apple Nachos Are the Perfect Fall Snack
Apple Nachos Are the Perfect Fall Snack
Stacey Bendet’s Ginger Tea Recipe 
Stacey Bendet’s Ginger Tea Recipe 
Chef K’s Vegan Churros with Vegan Chocolate Ganache
Chef K’s Vegan Churros with Vegan Chocolate Ganache
3 Minimal-Effort Recipes To Bring to a Labor Day Party
3 Minimal-Effort Recipes To Bring to a Labor Day Party
Kourt’s Favorite Egg Salad Salad
Kourt’s Favorite Egg Salad Salad
Chef K’s Mini Matcha Magpies
Chef K’s Mini Matcha Magpies
  • family
  • kourtney
Kourt’s New Weekly Tea Rotation During Her Pregnancy
Kourt’s New Weekly Tea Rotation During Her Pregnancy
Kourt’s First-Trimester Tips
Kourt’s First-Trimester Tips
5 Things To Know About Kourt’s New-ish Wellness Practice: Brain Mapping
5 Things To Know About Kourt’s New-ish Wellness Practice: Brain Mapping
Kourt’s Top Pregnancy Snacks
Kourt’s Top Pregnancy Snacks
Why Panchakarma is Kourt’s Holy Grail Detox
Why Panchakarma is Kourt’s Holy Grail Detox
How Last Weekend’s Gender Reveal Party Came Together in Less Than 48 Hours
How Last Weekend’s Gender Reveal Party Came Together in Less Than 48 Hours
What are you looking for?

Menu

  • Shop
  • HEALTH + WELLNESS
    • body
    • diy
    • fitness
    • Giving Back
    • health
    • mind
    • Relationships
    • Sexual Wellness
    • soul
  • HOME + ENTERTAINING
    • decor
    • entertaining
    • kids
    • motherhood
    • Playlists
    • recipes
  • KKB
    • family
    • kourtney
  • LIFE + STYLE
    • Adulting
    • beauty
    • guides
    • Hacks
    • style
    • travel
  • Newsletter
instagram pinterest facebook twitter youtube join newsletter
health

BMI is  BS

By Serena Nangia, Project HEAL
share on pinterest share on facebook share on twitter Share on Flipboard share by email
 Photo credit @javiera
@javiera

Every day in doctor’s offices around the country, patient measurements are taken in an antiquated fashion the moment they’re asked to step on a scale and their weight is put into a chart that estimates the Body Mass Index (BMI). The BMI is a generalized metric based on the ratio of weight to squared height that’s been proven ineffective and dangerous, yet is still the norm.

If someone’s weight lands above the BMI cutoff for obesity, the doctor will likely inform the patient that they are at risk for all sorts of illnesses, and the patient will be told to—of course—“lose weight.” Many of us have heard phrases like these, and they tend to incite shame as doctors often deliver these statements without tact or empathy.

So, why is BMI the standard and why doesn’t it work? Let’s take it back to the 1800s…

The first thing to know about the BMI is that it was created by a Belgian mathematician—not a doctor. In the 1830s, Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet set out to find the “l’homme moyen” or the “average man.” His belief was that if you could take thousands of measurements and compare them, you could find the “ideal weight.” Through calculating these samples, he found that weight typically increases in relation to the square height of a person, and the study became the standard BMI we use today.

There’s just a couple major problems with this. In an experiment meant to be for the “average man,” let it be known that Quetelet only conducted this on participants who were western European men. Not only that, but that experiment and its results were never meant to be applied to individuals. BMI was originally created with the purpose of studying populations and, therefore, it is commonly agreed upon by many health professionals that BMI is not an accurate measure of health.

Breaking it down further, BMI is a measurement determined by two physical characteristics: height and weight. The formula is simple: BMI = (weight in kilograms ÷ height in meters) BMI reflects only these two physical characteristics of a person while disregarding all other considerations.

Yet, most people believe that someone with a normal BMI is healthy and someone with a high BMI (categorized as “overweight” and “obese”) is unhealthy. This supports the false narratives that 1) the bigger an individual is, the more unhealthy they are, 2) all fat people are unhealthy, and 3) all thin people are healthy—all of which are simply not true.

The reality is that individuals can be healthy or unhealthy at any size, a principle commonly referred to as Health at Every Size (HAES).

For many decades, the definition of physical health has been the most common definition of “health,” period, but the real meaning of “health” is much more complex. The Center for Disease Control says that health is determined by a number of factors, including genetics, behavior, environmental and physical influences, medical care and social factors.

BMI should not be considered the sole determinant of health but should instead be only one deprioritized consideration alongside mental health, emotional and spiritual wellbeing, financial security, environmental safety, physical and mental ability, behavioral habits, cultural influences, and more.

Using BMI as the main indicator of individual health is killing people.

Using BMI as a main (if not only) indicator of health is not only theoretically problematic, but it also negatively impacts higher weight individuals substantially.

When determining a person’s health or diagnosis, many healthcare practitioners ignore and gloss over higher weight people’s ailments, pointing to an individual’s physical appearance and BMI rather than doing a thorough physical exam or mental wellness check.

This occurance is an example of weight stigma or weight bias which can be defined as “discriminatory acts and stigmatizing beliefs directed towards those perceived to carry excess weight.”

BMI as a whole is an obvious example of a systemically imposed and socialized form of weight bias. BMI is harmful to all people, but it especially impacts those in larger bodies. As a direct result, a 2012 study shows that the majority of doctor visits for patients in larger bodies are recorded as lasting a shorter length of time than visits from folks in thinner bodies for the same ailment.

This is problematic because people in larger bodies are therefore more likely to:

1) Get sick/injured and stay that way
2) Die from an illness that was not caught or caught at later stages
3) Avoid the doctor and medical facilities due to medical trauma

TL;DR

Any time a single number defines a whole human being, there is a huge risk that the human will be overlooked. And there is simply no scientific evidence that the BMI should be used as the main indicator of an individual’s health. It’s not logical, ethical, or precise, but one thing’s for certain—it is bullsh*t.

Serena Nangia has been working as an advocate for eating disorder recovery for over 8 years. She is the Marketing & Communications Manager at Project Heal, the leading nonprofit in the U.S. focused on equitable access to eating disorder and mental health treatment.

Up next, be the first to know our weekly content and sign up for our Poosh newsletter.

You may also like...

Go to article Do You Know Why You’re Angry?
health

Do You Know Why You’re Angry?

Go to article DYK: Morning Sunlight Is Naturally Healing Infrared 
health

DYK: Morning Sunlight Is Naturally Healing Infrared 

Related Articles

Goes to article These Are the Most Important Supplements for Brain Health
mind

These Are the Most Important Supplements for Brain Health

Goes to article 6 Foods That Are Good for Your Teeth 
health

6 Foods That Are Good for Your Teeth 

Goes to article What’s Actually Up with Those Artificial Dyes in Food? 
health

What’s Actually Up with Those Artificial Dyes in Food? 

Goes to article I Can’t Stop Taking Lemme Glow—And My Skin, Hair, and Nails Have Never Been Better
health

I Can’t Stop Taking Lemme Glow—And My Skin, Hair, and Nails Have Never Been Better

Goes to article Ingredient Spotlight: Castor Oil 
health

Ingredient Spotlight: Castor Oil 

Goes to article I’ve Embraced the Burn Thanks to Lemme’s New Capsules
health

I’ve Embraced the Burn Thanks to Lemme’s New Capsules

Goes to article 5 Moves To Boost Metabolism in the Morning
fitness

5 Moves To Boost Metabolism in the Morning

Goes to article Healthy Ways to Keep Glucose Spikes Down During Pregnancy 
health

Healthy Ways to Keep Glucose Spikes Down During Pregnancy 

  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • California Privacy Rights
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Accessibility

Keep in Touch

instagram pinterest facebook twitter youtube join newsletter
Reviewed by Allyant for Accessibility
  • © poosh, llc
    All Rights Reserved